Brutkey

Ron Jeffries
@RonJeffries@mastodon.social

@GeePawHill@mastodon.social
I'm wondering here ... ISTM ... just riffing here ...

ISTM that excellence is by definition rare. Every successful system (plant, animal, species, any complex system) succeeds not because of its most excellent elements, but because its mediocre elements are good enough.

Maybe what we, you and I, care about really doesn't matter to success, not because of extractive capitalism, bad as it is, or the like, but because excellence, by its nature, is just a lovely irrelevance.

1/2

Ron Jeffries
@RonJeffries@mastodon.social

@GeePawHill@mastodon.social

That might not even be bad. As we both know, striving for excellence is its own reward, quite often its only reward.

But it is a reward. You know, as I do, the joy of making.

I suspect that that joy, and the joy of sharing, of once in a while sparking someone ... might be what it's all about.

Mediocre works. It has to work. It's a fundamental law of complex systems (that I just identified).

2/3


Chris Pitts
@thirstybear@agilodon.social

@RonJeffries@mastodon.social @GeePawHill@mastodon.social โ€œMediocre worksโ€ is, I suspect, an element of the truism โ€œEvery system is perfectly designed to get the results it getsโ€.

And if the results the system gets through mediocrity are good enoughโ€ฆboom
๐Ÿ’ฅ๐Ÿ’ฅ Which is precisely the reason LLMs might just succeed in killling off software development-they might be โ€œgood enoughโ€ mediocre.

Which I find depressing as hell having strived to raise the bar and make a difference my entire career.

Poligofsky ๐Ÿ‡จ๐Ÿ‡ฆ๐Ÿ‡จ๐Ÿ‡ฆ
@8r3n7@mstdn.ca

@thirstybear@agilodon.social

If I mayโ€ฆ

โ€œExcellentโ€ and โ€œmediocreโ€ are subjective and relative. They are aesthetic judgements, based on some set of preferred criteria. Otherwise, not disagreeing.

The reason that โ€œmediocreโ€ softwareโ€”bloated, buggy, insecureโ€”succeeds is that the competitive market landscape is characterized by winner-take-all. Upstarts get strangled in their cribs, if they are born at all.

The software ecosystem is not healthy. It has similarities to industrial agriculture.

@RonJeffries@mastodon.social @GeePawHill@mastodon.social